Category Archives: Varia

Moitessier and Paladilhe: collections

Prosper-Antoine Moitessier (1807-1867) is more famous for having been an organ builder. He wrote some papers relative to malacology and his collection was sold to the dealer Damon in 1867 (after Dance, 1966). Maybe a part of the Moitessier’s collection is housed into the collections of the Natural History Museum (NHMUK).
In 1880’s, Georges Coutagne was preparing his revision of the genus Moitessieria. He wrote to almost all malacologists having representatives of this genus in their collection, and tried to check all types. The localisation of “old” collections was therefore required.
Within this context, Coutagne wrote to Albert Moitessier (1833-1889), son of Prosper-Antoine. He was a medical doctor, and professor at the University of Montpellier. However, Albert Moitessier had sold the collection of his father, without remembering the name of the purchaser. He proposed to find the collections of some very close relations of his father in malacology as Dr. Paladilhe and Dubreuil.

“Montpellier, 3 février 1882
Monsieur, je regrette bien vivement de ne pouvoir vous venir en aide dans votre travail. La collection de mon père n’est plus en ma possession. Elle a été vendue, à l’époque de sa mort en Angleterre, et je n’en ai conservé, comme souvenir, que quelques coquilles sans intérêt scientifique. Les quelques espèces du genre Moitessieria, que j’aurais désiré conserver, n’ont pu m’être cédées, à aucune condition par l’acquéreur, qui paraissaient y tenir beaucoup.
Je puis cependant vous donner un renseignement, bien vague sans doute et probablement inutile, mais qui vous permettrait peut-être de retrouver quelques espèces de ce genre, mon père avait pour ami le docteur Paladilhe, amateur passionné et heureux dans la recherche des petites espèces. Mr Paladilhe est mort en laissant une collection fort intéressante. J’ignore ce qu’est devenue cette collection car la famille a quitté Montpellier. Je ne pense pas toutefois que cette collection ait été détruite car elle ne renfermait rien de séduisant pour les yeux incompétents. Il me serait peut-être possible d’en retrouver la trace et je me mets à votre disposition pour rechercher ce qu’elle est devenue. J’ignore toutefois si elle renfermait la M. gervaisiana.
Peut-être, aussi, pourriez-vous avoir quelques indications auprès de Mr. Dubrueil de Montpellier, qui avait des relations avec Paladilhe. Mr Dubrueil possède une intéressante collection de mollusques terrestres et fluviatiles de France. Il ne serait pas impossible qu’il ait recueilli quelques espèces de la succession Paladilhe.
Agréez, je vous prie, l’expression de les sentiments distingués.
A. Moitessier”

002

001 [1]

The collection of Paladilhe is housed in University of Montpellier.

Source:
[1] Musée des Confluences, Centre de conservation et d’étude des collections, Lyon

Reference
Dance SP. 1966. Shell collecting. An illustrated history. Los Angeles/Berkely: University of California Press, 345 pp.

 

 

 

Season’s Greetings

Since I became so interested in networks between malacologists in the past, my Season’s Greetings for this year are devoted to this topic. Here you find the original of this card, with further context. But below is the explanation given for those who want to know if they know all these malacologists.

kn2016explanationAnd above (inverted in gray) is the answer on the question “Who is the man whose son can be seen here twice?”…

Moricand: a letter in a book

A large collection of reprints and separata are owned by the library of the Centre de conservation et d’étude des collections in Lyon. Reading a binded volume of miscellanea of Stefano Moricand (1779-1854), we found inside a letter written by Moricand addressed to Ange-Paulin Terver (1798-1875). The handwritting style is quite similar to his correspondant, with a minute handwritting and thick downstrokes.

The letter is dated on 21 May, 1836, and reads as follows.

“Monsieur, j’ai reçu dans le temps l’ouvrage de Mr. Michaud que vous avez bien voulu m’envoyer ; qui m’a fait grand plaisir. Ayant inutilement cherché et attendu une occasion pour vous faire passer mes petits mémoires & craignant que mon silence en se prolongeant se pût être mal interprété, je me décide à vous les envoyer par la messagerie, ils vous serviront de catalogue pour vos desiderata, car je ne crois pas avoir conservé de note de ce que je vous ai envoyé. Quand vous recevrez vos coquilles d’Alger je me recommande à votre bon souvenir; je vous prie d’agréer l’assurance de mon (ill.) dévouement. Stefano Morricand” [signed with double r].

numeriser-1

[1]

The interpretation of this letter sheds a new light on the activities of Terver. As collaborator of Michaud, he drew the lithographs for the Supplement to Draparnaud (Michaud 1831); this was likely the book sent to Moricand. Terver was apparently preparing his study of the Algerian fauna (which was published in 1839). From the letter is becomes obvious that Moricand and Terver exchanged not only books but also shells. And finally, we learn that the catalogues of Moricand (1834, 1836) were likely to be used to mark the oblata!

Note:
[1] Source: CCEC.

References:
Michaud G. 1831. Complément de l’Histoire naturelle des Mollusques terrestres et fluviatiles de la France, de J. P. R. Draparnaud. Paris / Montpellier, 1–128, pl. XIV-XVI.
Moricand S. 1834. Note sur quelques espèces nouvelles de coquilles terrestres. Mémoires de la Société de Physique et d’Histoire naturelle de Genève 6: 537-543, pl. I.
Moricand S. 1836. Mémoire sur les coquilles terrestres et fluviatiles envoyées de Bahia par M. S. Blanchet. Mémoires de la Société de Physique et d’Histoire naturelle de Genève 7 (2): 415-446, pl. II.
Terver A-P. 1839. Catalogue des Mollusques terrestres et fluviatiles observés dans les possessions françaises au nord de l’Afrique. Paris / Lyon: J.-B. Baillière, Crochard & Savy, 1–39, 4 pl.

General de Lamothe: collection and collectors

General Léon de Lamothe (1849–1936) is a French geologist and malacologist whose collections are housed in Muséum d’Histoire naturelle in Grenoble. He brought together a large collection, building upon his father’s collection. Benjamin de Lamothe (1799–1884) was a colonel and we know he had collected molluscs himself, as evidenced by some labels (“collection de mon père et recueilli par lui”). This collection contained a few hundreds lots of specimens. His son Léon increased this collection by collecting especially in Algeria, when he was there in garrison during the 1910s. With an important network of conchologists, he practiced exchanges and purchases to constitute a worlwide collection that contained both marine and continental, with local and exotical species. L. de Lamothe worked in close cooperation with Philippe Dautzenberg (1849–1935), the most frequent name who appears in his collection. Dautzenberg gave him (or exchanged with him) many specimens, identified his samples and validated them before publication (e.g.: de Lamothe published some catalogues for the Algerian malacofauna, in particular Arzew and Mostaganem).

DSC_9624a[1]

Another important collaborator of de Lamothe was the Commandant L. Morlet (1823–1892) who provided him with many exotical species.
The names of many other collectors can also be found in his collection: General Léon de Beylié (1849–1910), a patron for Musée de Grenoble (ethnology and archeology), Captain Le Chatelier, Marquis de Monterosato, Henri Gouin, Chaper, Darbois, Flamand, Sowerby, Newcombe, Smith, etc. He purchased molluscs from Vigné, Géret and most of all, Boulanger. Ancey is mentioned as a persons who performed the determinations. Finally a large serie of molluscs came from the Gruvel mission in 1909–1910 (with Chudeau along the coast of the West African) and another from “Germain’s mission in 1907” (probably the mission of Chudeau in Lake Chad).

Note:
[1] Annotated copy of L. de Lamothe’s work about marine malacology in MHNGr.

Shells dealers

From the middle of 19th century, a strongly development of shell trade is observed, in particular, the retail sale and the sale by mail order (see also Dance, 1966, 1969).

Hermann Rolle (1864–1929) was a famous German dealer in Berlin specialised in ornithology and conchology. He acquired several important collections and stocks of material (e.g. Möllendorf). His store was immense, especially for palaearctic shells. We have a copy of his catalogue which has to be dated ca. 1894 [1]. The prices are given in Deutsche mark, but foreign customers found the exchange rates directly on the cover.

Sowerby & Fulton is another well-known house for shells, based in London. The mail order catalogue is written like a scientific publication, including a systematic order following the last classification (Pilsbry and Tryon’s Manual of Conchology; Sykes (1900) for Achatinellidae; Kobelt & Möllendorf (1890), etc.), with genera, subgenera and sections, authors for species and synonyms for genera, e.g.Chondrella 1871 = Diadema 1868 non Schaum 1817 = Garrettia 1874)”. Sowerby & Fulton wanted to be always up-to-date with a serious proposal and precise identifications.

Each booklet provides an index of generic names. The copy we have is dated between 1902 to 1906 [2] and it includes six booklets:
Inoperculate land shells (April 1902)
Cephalopoda, Pteropoda, Gastropoda (marine and freshwater) and Scaphopoda (April 1903)
Pelecypoda and Brachiopoda (June 1903)
Operculate land shells (1906)
For these five booklets, the prices are not given: specimens are sent on approval.
Recent shells (August 1902) is a compendium with a wide selection (almost 900 genera); the prices are given in shillings, with francs and mark equivalent.

Compared to Rolle’s catalogue, the scope is entirely on the worldwide malacofauna. The number of species is very substantial. Both catalogues were adressed to French, English and German collectors (the introduction in Rolle’s catalogue is even provided in three languages); many conchologists purchased specimens from these two shell suppliers and material of Rolle and Sowerby & Fulton can be found in most European museums.

style=”width:100%;height:100%;”

Rolle Sowerby & Fulton

Reference:
Dance SP. 1969. Rare shells. Berkeley and Los Angeles, University of California Press, 128 p.

[1, 2] Source: Audibert, private library

Malacology during the First World War

We provide two postcards [1] written from malacologists at the beginning of the First World War in 1914, between France and Italy.

In the first one, Philéas Rousseau (1860–1935), a French malacologist who was interested in botany and zoology (he published two catalogues dealing with molluscs and vascular plants of the island of Ré, near La Rochelle), wrote to Raimondo del Prete (1850–1937), an Italian malacologist. This letter is dated August 27, 1914, just one month after the beginning of the war. He expressed concern about a parcel with shells sent to him one month ago (thus just some days before France entered the war!) and asked him to stop the shipments until a return to calm: “Veuillez donc je vous prie, me donner des nouvelles du colis postal de Coquilles que je vous ai adressé il y a un mois. Vous devez comprendre mon inquiétude à ce sujet en raison de la tourmente que nous traversons. Vouloir bien attendre des temps plus tranquilles pour m’expédier le vôtre ; ça ne presse pas“.

The second postcard is written by Commandant Eugène Caziot (1844–1931) from Alpes-Maritimes (France) and adressed to Francesco Settepassi (1889–1982), a young Italian malacologist, living in Viareggio as R. del Prete. The card is dated November 1, 1914, two months after the letter of Ph. Rousseau to del Prete and the declaration of war with France (August 3, 1914). Unlike Ph. Rousseau, Caziot is less cautious with sendings and continue his activity in an ever more troubled world. However, in this postcard, Caziot is worried about his last sending (probably a parcel of shells) and a consecutive letter, both remained without response: “Je vous ai fait connaître que je vous faisais un envoi ; je vous ai adressé une carte 15 jours après. Je n’ai pas reçu ni avis ni réponse. Vous seriez aimable de me sortir d’inquiétude“.

Reference:
Vimpère J., 2015. Découverte d’un inventaire manuscrit des Mollusques de la Vendée rédigé par Edmond Bocquier (1881-1948). Folia conchyliologica, 31: 3-13 [Notice on Ph. Rousseau, portr., p. 9]

[1] Source: Audibert, private collection

Specimens from the second expedition of Dumont d’Urville

The second expedition under the Dumont d’Urville’s command (Voyage of the Astrolabe and the Zélée) took place between September 7, 1837 and November 6, 1840. Molluscs (more 150 species described) were studied by Louis François Emmanuel Rousseau from Hombron and Jacquinot’s collections, which are currently housed in MNHN.

Some historical specimens from this expedition can be found in the collections of Musée des Confluences in Lyon. One of them (inv. 45036286) which had been taken in Australia (and thus collected in 1839 or in early 1840) came from the collection of Hector Nicolas (1834–1899) acquired by Gustave Sayn.

20160802_100536[1]

The identification of handwritings will aid to the understanding of whom Nicolas obtained this specimen. Nevertheless another information is given on the back of the label: “Origine: Aubert. Toulon”.

In the first volume of Dumont d’Urville’s book, “M. Aubert” appears (p. 31) : “Nous y rencontrâmes M. Berthelot, ancien aspirant de la marine à Toulon, et M. Aubert, autre Français établi comme lui à la ville de l’Orotava”. La Orotava is a municipality located in the northern part of Tenerife. A specific searching on Google with “Aubert + Oritava” allows us to learn more about this person: Pierre-Alexandre Aubert was a member of the Academy of Madrid and a mathematics teacher in the College of Orotava [2] and maybe natural history with Berthelot [3].

References:
Dumont d’Urville J. 1830. Voyage de la corvette L’Astrolabe exécuté par ordre du Roi, pendant les années 1826-1827-1828-1829 sous le commandement de M. J. Dumont d’Urville, capitaine de vaisseau, publié par ordonnance de Sa Majesté. Histoire du voyage. Tome premier. Paris: J. Tastut, I–CXVI, 1–528, tab.
Rousseau L. 1854.
Description des mollusques coquilles et zoophytes. In Hombron JB. & Jacquinot CH. Voyage au Pôle Sud et dans l’Océanie sur les corvettes l’Astrolabe et la Zélée, exécuté par ordre du Roi pendant les années 1837-1838-1839-1840, sous le commandement de M. J. Dumont d’Urville, capitaine de vaisseau, publié par ordonnance de Sa Majesté, sous la direction supérieure de M. Jacquinot, capitaine de vaisseau, commandant de la Zélée. Tome cinquième. Paris, i–viii, 1–132.

Notes:
[1] CCEC.
[2] In Report of M. Josy on a manuscript related to Tenerife Island (April 16, 1828). In: Bulletin de la Société de Géographie 84 (April 1830): 162–170 (p. 162).
[3] Ein Streifzug durch die Kanaren – Anthropologie (online). Guanchen – Affen – Menschen ?? Canaria Archiv